linuxaudio.org

--14dae934088d0ff8a704d58873c9

Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1
Hey James!
Kinsella argues copyright from the point of view of non-aggression, i.e.

property rights.
As for your question, as to how will people make a living who do IP only?

Consider an analogy which is brought up often.

Say, there is a culture where women are being forced to marry men that their

family chooses. As you know, in many countries around the world in the past

this was standard stuff.

And now imagine someone saying that this is wrong and brings in his

argumentation.

And someone says - well, then how will my sister get married?
Or if you are against slavery, someone will tell you - well, then how will

the work

in this country be done if there are no slaves? Who will want to do it?
The real question is - I don't know. All I know is that forced

marriage/slavery/copyright are wrong and here are

my arguments.

I don't see a problem with that position.
As pointed out on my site, producing IP is necessary. How will people get

paid?

In various different ways. Just like they get paid now. In Russia copyright

law is

not enforced that much, yet Russia has scientists, composers, actors and

movie directors.

So they must be getting paid somehow.
L.V.
--14dae934088d0ff8a704d58873c9

Content-Type: text/html; charset=ISO-8859-1

Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Hey James!Kinsella argues copyright from the point of view of non-a=

ggression, i.e.property rights.As for your question, as to how =

will people make a living who do IP only?Consider an analogy which is b=

rought up often.

Say, there is a culture where women are being forced to marry men that thei=

rfamily chooses. As you know, in many countries around the world in the=

 pastthis was standard stuff.And now imagine someone saying that th=

is is wrong and brings in his argumentation.

And someone says - well, then how will my sister get married?Or if =

you are against slavery, someone will tell you - well, then how will the wo=

rkin this country be done if there are no slaves? Who will want to do i=

t?

The real question is - I don't know. All I know is that forced marr=

iage/slavery/copyright are wrong and here aremy arguments.I don&#39=

;t see a problem with that position.As pointed out on my site, prod=

ucing IP is necessary. How will people get paid?

In various different ways. Just like they get paid now. In Russia copyright=

 law isnot enforced that much, yet Russia has scientists, composers, ac=

tors and movie directors.So they must be getting paid somehow.

L.V.
--14dae934088d0ff8a704d58873c9--