linuxaudio.org

Josh Lawrence wrote:

quoted text
> On 8/15/06, Patrick Shirkey  wrote:

>> Maybe in your world we all get respect as artists and everyone has the

>> time to contact a major label to get permission to use a 5 second sample

>> in a remix they are making for a demo or to share with a few friends.

>

> This argument doesn't seem to make sense.  So what you are saying is:

>

> 1)Because the original owner is not conveniently accessible to you,

> the rules do not apply.  Therefore, any rule/law that is inconvenient

> does not apply.

In the context of music as art I would say yes.
> 2)Because the use is personal (shared among friends), rules do not apply.
Try to stop the unwashed masses from sharing songs illegally. A

pragmatic approach says it is currently impossible without draconian

measures in place to monitor all forms of digital data transfer. If you

want to help big brother out keep going down that road...
> 3)Those who do see the value in a shared standard of rules/laws are

quoted text
> from another world.

> 

Beep, Wrong. If you live in a world where all artists get respect and

have time (or even resources) to get permission to use samples of

licensed work for every little remix they do then you must be in a

different world.
> This is situational ethics.  Changing the rules in the middle of the

quoted text
> game, no matter how much the rules suck, is morally wrong.  If you

> disagree with the rules, don't play the game, or work to change them.

>

> Or did I misunderstand this line of thinking?

> 

So, if I have no morals or don't subscribe to the same set of standards

that you do does it mean I am a lesser artist than someone who does?
Lesser person maybe but what has it got to do with art?
If I actively work against the rules does that constitute working

towards change?
--

Patrick Shirkey - Boost Hardware Ltd.

Http://www.boosthardware.com

Http://lau.linuxaudio.org - The Linux Audio Users guide

========================================
"Anything your mind can see you can manifest physically, then it will

become reality" - Macka B